Past Masters
- 1896 Frisby Doub
- 1897 Frisby Doub
- 1898 Frisby Doub
- 1899 Frisby Doub
- 1900 Joshua W. Rohrer
- 1901 Joshua W. Rohrer
- 1902 William M. Nihiser
- 1903 John A. Miller
- 1904 Joshua C. Hines
- 1905 Thomas H. Hutzell
- 1906 D.A. Nunamaker
- 1907 D.A. Nunamaker
- 1908 S. S. Davis
- 1909 William C. Geeting
- 1910 William C. Geeting
- 1911 Jacob R. Hoover
- 1912 G. H. Sprecher
- 1913 Dr. A. D. Baker
- 1914 C. W. Eakle
- 1915 William S. Leatherman
- 1916 S. A. Gates
- 1917 George W. Buxten
- 1918 George W. Buxten
- 1919 George S. Line
- 1920 John V. Alexander
- 1921 Alvin H. Line
- 1922 Russell H. Geeting
- 1923 Charles B. Taylor
- 1924 Elmer G. Miller
- 1925 Elmer G. Miller
- 1926 Henry Edgar Snyder
- 1927 Leroy E. Jennings
- 1928 Charles K. Taylor
- 1929 Charles K. Taylor
- 1930 Paul N. Wyand
- 1931 Paul N. Wyand
- 1932 Clarence Wade Folz
- 1933 Clarence Wade Folz
- 1934 George B. Snively
- 1935 George B. Snively
- 1936 Daniel E. Nicodemus
- 1937 Daniel E. Nicodemus
- 1938 Russell Isiah Earnshaw
- 1939 Russell Isiah Earnshaw
- 1940 Russell Isiah Earnshaw
- 1941 George W. Buxton
- 1942 George B. Snively
- 1943 Clarence Wade Folz
- 1944 Clarence Wade Folz
- 1945 Raymond W. Kaetzel
- 1946 Raymond W. Kaetzel
- 1947 W. Page Ditto
- 1948 Lee G. Garnand
- 1949 Lee G. Garnand
- 1950 Lloyd W. Thompson
- 1951 Glenn C. Haynes
- 1952 Glenn C. Haynes
- 1953 Joseph E. Beeler
- 1954 Robert Rice Wyand
- 1955 Robert Rice Wyand
- 1956 Richard Hartley Moser
- 1957 Richard Hartley Moser
- 1958 W. Page Ditto
- 1959 W. Page Ditto
- 1960 Elwood E. Younkins
- 1961 Elwood E. Younkins
- 1962 Leonard U. Higdon
- 1963 Leonard U. Higdon
- 1964 Stanley James Taylor
- 1965 Stanley James Taylor
- 1966 George Albert Miller, Jr.
- 1967 Ralph Arthur Holmes
- 1968 Ralph Arthur Holmes
- 1969 Ralph Arthur Holmes
- 1970 Ralph Arthur Holmes
- 1971 A. Blair Beauchamp
- 1972 A. Blair Beauchamp
- 1973 A. Blair Beauchamp
- 1974 A. Blair Beauchamp
- 1975 A. Blair Beauchamp
- 1976 James Brown Bachtell
- 1977 James Brown Bachtell
- 1978 James Brown Bachtell
- 1979 James Brown Bachtell
- 1980 James Brown Bachtell
- 1981 James Brown Bachtell
- 1982 James Brown Bachtell
- 1983 James Brown Bachtell
- 1984 James Brown Bachtell
- 1985 James Brown Bachtell
- 1986 James Brown Bachtell
- 1987 James Brown Bachtell
- 1988 James Brown Bachtell
- 1989 James Brown Bachtell
- 1990 William E. Eisentrout
- 1991 William E. Eisentrout
- 1992 William E. Eisentrout
- 1993 William E. Eisentrout
- 1994 William E. Eisentrout
- 1995 William E. Eisentrout
- 1996 William E. Eisentrout
- 1997 William E. Eisentrout
- 1998 J. Thomas Stouffer
- 1999 J. Thomas Stouffer
- 2000 J. Thomas Stouffer
- 2001 J. Thomas Stouffer
- 2002 J. Thomas Stouffer
- 2003 J. Thomas Stouffer
- 2004 J. Thomas Stouffer
- 2005 J. Thomas Stouffer
- 2006 J. Thomas Stouffer
- 2007 J. Thomas Stouffer
- 2008 J. Thomas Stouffer
- 2009 J. Thomas Stouffer
- 2010 J. Thomas Stouffer